Currency

Back to the resources
Personality disordersFor practitioners85 min read

Narcissistic personality: a therapist's manual

A sixteen-key-session protocol, within treatment lasting about a year, for adults whose self-worth depends on superiority and admiration, in a grandiose or vulnerable form. First an alliance that avoids both humiliation and collusive admiration, goals framed in the patient's own terms, and an assessment that looks for depression and suicide risk after an injury. Then the cycle of fragile worth, what superiority protects and costs, and shame, recognised and named. Next criticism and failure, anger and devaluation, excessive demands, the place of the other person, repair and reciprocity. A realistic sense of self-worth, the distinction from the popular figure of the "narcissistic pervert", an honest account of the level of evidence, and references.

In short

This manual is written for mental health professionals trained in cognitive behavioural therapy and in work with personality disorders. It covers narcissistic personality in adults: a sense of one's own importance, a need for admiration, a sense of entitlement, empathy that fails when it matters, and, beneath these traits, fragile self-worth, great sensitivity to criticism and failure, and a shame rarely voiced. The disorder takes two forms that often alternate in the same person: a grandiose form, self-assured and domineering, and a vulnerable form, touchy, anxious and withdrawn. These patients rarely seek help for their narcissism. They come after a failure, a humiliation, a break-up, a conflict at work, a depression, or because a partner is threatening to leave. The programme rests on a precise reading: what is treated is not pride, but the dependence of self-worth on superiority, and the shame that every threat reawakens. So you avoid two symmetrical errors — confronting in a humiliating way, which drives the patient away, and admiring them to keep them in treatment, which traps them —, you name the shame beneath the anger, you treat criticism and failure as events one can get through, and you give the other person back their place. The manual pays particular attention to suicide risk after an injury, distinguishes this disorder from the popular figure of the "narcissistic pervert", and says what it does not know: no trial specifically addresses this disorder.

Topic
Personality disorders
Who it's for
For practitioners
Languages
FR · EN · DE · IT · ES · ZH · AR

Français · English · Deutsch · Italiano · Español · 中文 · العربية

The programme

This programme is a treatment manual for mental health professionals. It assumes clinical training, experience with personality disorders, and a supervision framework. It replaces neither your clinical judgement nor your professional responsibility. Diagnostic criteria are reworded here in our own words, never reproduced. Two warnings specific to this indication. A narcissistic injury — a public failure, a break-up, a disgrace — is a moment of suicide risk often underestimated in a patient who seemed self-assured, section 9. And the level of evidence is thin: no controlled trial specifically addresses this disorder, which section 11 sets out plainly.

1. The programme at a glance

Indication. Narcissistic personality in adults, as outpatients, in a grandiose or vulnerable form, with distress or impairment, and a request that the patient makes — even indirectly.

Reference model. Cognitive therapy for personality disorders, centred on conditional self-worth, shame and defensive responses to threat, enriched with elements borrowed from schema therapy for understanding modes — the self-aggrandising mode, the detached self-soothing mode, the vulnerable part —, and with work on the capacity to represent others' mental states under stress.

Format. Treatment lasting about a year, some forty sessions; this manual describes sixteen key sessions, organised in five phases, with the points of extension indicated. 50-minute sessions, weekly. Booster sessions. Vigilance about early dropout, which is common in this indication.

Targeted mechanism. Make visible the cycle linking conditional self-worth, threat, shame and defensive responses; recognise and name shame; get through criticism and failure without collapsing or attacking; reduce anger and devaluation; soften excessive demands; restore the capacity to perceive the other person; repair; and build a sense of self-worth that can bear the ordinary.

Phase Session Focus Session deliverable
I. Alliance 1 Meeting without humiliating Reason for coming stated, patient's competence acknowledged
2 Goals in the patient's own terms Goals chosen, written framework
3 Assess Mood, suicide risk and consequences assessed
II. Understand 4 The cycle of fragile worth Cycle drawn with a real episode
5 What superiority protects and costs Balance written
6 Shame Shame identified beneath two reactions
III. Change 7 Criticism and failure One criticism got through differently
8 Anger and devaluation Response delay established
9 Demands and perfectionism Two demands softened
10 Mid-point review Measures repeated, plan revised
IV. Relationships 11 The other person exists A situation reviewed from the other person's point of view
12 Repairing A repair prepared and made
13 Reciprocity An exchange rebalanced
V. Consolidate 14 What lies beneath Beliefs and history linked
15 A realistic sense of self-worth Values written, the ordinary accepted
16 Review, relapse, next steps Plan written, measures repeated

What distinguishes this programme from the other manuals on this site. Three things. A patient who can idealise and then devalue their therapist in the same month. A shame that is almost never spoken and that organises everything. And a suicide risk hidden behind self-assurance.

2. Before you begin

Who this programme is for

Psychologists, psychiatrists and psychotherapists trained in cognitive behavioural therapy, with experience of personality disorders, who can rely on supervision. These treatments test the therapist in a particular way: being admired, then scorned, being put in competition, having one's competence challenged. There needs to be a place to talk about it.

The four preliminary decisions

1. Which form dominates? Grandiose, vulnerable, or alternating. The form changes how to engage the patient. Sections 3 and 36.

2. Is there depression or suicide risk? Particularly after a failure, a break-up, a disgrace, legal proceedings. Section 9.

3. Is there violence? Towards a partner, children, subordinates, or coercive control. Section 35.

4. What is the patient asking for? Often not "to change my personality". Rather: to stop being depressed, to save their relationship, to resolve a conflict at work. That is the request you accept.

What this programme does not treat

Patients in whom antisocial traits dominate, with exploitation of others, transgression and violence, who fall under the corresponding manual and a risk assessment.

Manic or hypomanic episodes, in which grandiosity is episodic.

Situations of active intimate partner violence, which call first for the victim's protection and a specialised programme for the perpetrator.

What this programme is not

It is not a therapy that humiliates the patient to "bring their ego down". Nor is it a therapy that confirms them in their superiority to stop them leaving. It is not a treatment for victims of narcissistic people, who need a different kind of help.

How to use it

Read sections 3 to 14 first: they ground the choices made in the sessions. Read section 31 before the first session: the alliance is at stake from the outset, and early dropout is common. The sessions described are key sessions; each may take two or three. Section 39 sets out what must not be dropped.

3. The clinical picture

What defines the disorder

A lasting, pervasive pattern of grandiosity — in fantasy or behaviour —, a need for admiration and a lack of empathy, present since early adulthood and across a range of contexts.

The forms it takes

An exaggerated sense of one's own importance: exaggerating achievements, expecting to be recognised as superior.

Fantasies of unlimited success, power, brilliance, beauty or ideal love.

The conviction of being special, of being understandable only by high-status people or institutions.

An excessive need for admiration.

A sense of entitlement: expecting special treatment, expecting others to fall in with one's expectations.

Exploiting others to achieve one's ends.

A lack of empathy: difficulty or unwillingness to recognise others' feelings and needs.

Envy, or the conviction of being envied.

Arrogance, haughty attitudes.

The two forms

The grandiose form: self-assurance, dominance, active pursuit of admiration, charm, exploitation, anger when contradicted. It is visible, and seldom seeks help.

The vulnerable form: touchiness, anxiety, shame, withdrawal, a sense of being misunderstood or unrecognised, resentment, secretly held fantasies of greatness, depression. It seeks help more often, and is often mistaken for avoidant personality or depression.

The two forms often alternate in the same person: grandiose when all is well, vulnerable after a failure. The classifications mainly describe the first; clinical practice often meets the second.

What patients describe

Rarely narcissism. They describe a world that does not recognise their worth, mediocre or jealous colleagues, a partner who does not understand them, unjust failures. They also describe, when the alliance allows, an exhaustion at having to shine, a fear of being exposed as ordinary, an emptiness, a loneliness in the midst of admiration, and a shame that can become unbearable.

What you see in the consultation

Depending on the form: a self-assurance that seeks to impress, questions about the therapist's qualifications, a way of correcting or dominating the exchange; or a wounded reserve, touchiness at the slightest remark, a complaint of being misunderstood. In both cases, great sensitivity to anything resembling a judgement, and rapid swings between idealisation and devaluation of the therapist.

Epidemiology

General population estimates vary widely depending on methods. The categorical diagnosis is more often made in men. The vulnerable form is probably underdiagnosed. The disorder is associated with relationship difficulties, depression, substance use, and suicide risk after setbacks.

4. The cycle of fragile worth

The model guiding this programme is cognitive and interpersonal. It is presented to the patient without jargon, and without the word "narcissism" if they do not use it.

The central piece

Conditional self-worth: I'm only worth something if I'm exceptional; being ordinary means being worthless; if I'm not the best, I'm nothing. It comes with an excessive ideal self and a shame lurking behind every gap between oneself and that ideal.

It forms in a variety of histories — worth granted only for achievements, boundless admiration that never learned to bear the ordinary, neglect or humiliation that made superiority necessary —, and you do not impose it.

The links

1. A situation of comparison or evaluation. Criticism, a failure, a colleague promoted, a partner less attentive, a look, an expectation.

2. Perceived threat. The gap from the ideal becomes visible: they're going to see I'm not so exceptional.

3. Shame, often brief, rarely conscious, almost never voiced.

4. The defensive response, in one of three forms:

attack — anger, devaluing the other person, contempt, retaliation;

overcompensation — self-aggrandisement, reminding others of one's achievements, dominating;

withdrawal — isolating oneself, self-soothing by solitary means, substance use, losing interest.

5. The immediate effect. Shame is kept at bay, self-worth restored for a while. The response is reinforced.

6. Others' reactions. Conflicts, distancing, lost relationships, professional sanctions, isolation.

7. The confirmation, in two forms: other people are mediocre and jealous — which maintains grandiosity — or I'm worthless — which opens onto collapse.

Collapse

When defences are no longer enough — a massive failure, a break-up, public disgrace, illness, ageing —, shame overflows. This is the moment of depression, substance use, and suicide risk. Section 33.

Empathy under threat

Many narcissistic patients can represent what others feel; they often do so very well when they are not threatened. It is under threat that the other person disappears, reduced to an obstacle or a mirror. So the work bears less on learning empathy than on its availability when shame is present.

What the treatment does

It makes the cycle visible, teaches recognition and naming of shame, replaces defensive responses with other ways of getting through threat, softens demands and conditional self-worth, gives the other person back their place, and builds a sense of self-worth that can bear the ordinary.

What the model explains to the patient

That they have set the bar very high, and are paying the price. That their reactions of anger or withdrawal protect them from real pain. That this protection is costing them their relationships and sometimes their career. And that it is possible to learn to bear not being exceptional at every moment, without ceasing to be someone.

5. Ordinary narcissism, the popular figure and the disorder

Why this section exists

Because the word "narcissistic" is everywhere: in the media, self-help books, social media, separations. It sometimes denotes ordinary self-confidence, sometimes a difficult partner, sometimes a predator. This confusion harms patients who really have the disorder, and people who suffer from it around them.

What needs to be distinguished

Healthy self-esteem, stable, able to bear criticism and failure.

Ordinary narcissism, a personality trait present in everyone to varying degrees, sometimes useful — ambition, self-assurance, leadership.

Marked narcissistic traits, without major distress or impairment.

Narcissistic personality disorder, with rigid functioning and impairment.

The "narcissistic pervert"

This term, very widespread in the French-speaking world, is not a diagnosis: it appears in neither the DSM-5-TR nor the ICD-11. It came from psychoanalytic thinking, and has become a popular figure denoting a manipulative, cold, destructive person in relationships. What the term describes may, depending on the case, fall under narcissistic personality, antisocial personality, psychopathy, or behaviours of violence and coercive control that correspond to no personality disorder.

What you do: you do not use it as a diagnosis. You hear the suffering of people who use it to describe what they have been through, and refer them to appropriate help, especially in cases of violence or coercive control. You do not use it for a patient.

The weight of the label

The diagnosis of narcissistic personality is today a common insult. Announcing it bluntly to a patient with fragile self-worth can provoke a rupture or a collapse. You describe the difficulties, talk about fragile self-worth and sensitivity to criticism, and answer honestly if the patient asks.


This programme is for practitioners

It is written for mental health professionals and requires credential verification, then a professional subscription.

Frequently asked questions

Should the diagnosis be disclosed? With caution. The term is often experienced as an insult. You talk about fragile self-worth, sensitivity to criticism, very high standards. If the patient asks, you answer honestly.

The patient tells me I'm the best therapist he's ever met. Accept it without feeding on it, and prepare for the moment he will be disappointed. Section 31.

He tells me I'm incompetent. Do not defend yourself, look for the injury, and acknowledge your part if there is one. Section 31.

He seems very self-assured: is it really necessary to ask about suicide? Yes, especially after a failure, a break-up or a disgrace. Section 33.

His wife calls to tell me he is a narcissistic pervert. Listen, make no diagnosis on the basis of that account, respect confidentiality, assess safety, and refer her to help for herself. Section 34.

He asks for special times and a negotiated fee. The same answer as for any other patient, given respectfully. Section 14.

He only talks about his successes. Acknowledge them, then come back to what brings him and what is not going well. Look for what those stories protect.

He acknowledges everything, but nothing changes. Check that the work is touching shame, and not just ideas. A brilliant understanding can be a new way of dominating the session. Section 32.

Is it narcissistic or antisocial personality? Look at what drives the behaviour: admiration and superiority, or gain and transgression. The two sometimes coexist. Sections 7 and 36.

How long? About a year, with booster sessions. Often longer for severe forms.

Printable worksheets

The exercises from this programme, as printable PDFs. Members only.

See the plansThe printable worksheets are included with access.
  1. 01What I want to achieveIn my own terms, and in facts.
  2. 02My circleWhen something gets to me, what I do, and what follows.
  3. 03Just beforeWhat you feel when you feel exposed.
  4. 04Criticism and angerA criticism is about a moment, not about a whole person.
  5. 05Other peopleThose who admire, and those who know.
  6. 06From demands to valuesWhat will remain when I am no longer the top performer.
  7. 07When I am hurtWritten in a calm moment, for a time when everything will seem lost.

Every worksheet in one file, with a table of contents.

narcissistic personalitynarcissistic personality disorderpathological narcissismgrandiose narcissismvulnerable narcissismshameself-esteemcriticismfailureempathyangerdevaluationnarcissistic pervertpersonality disordersprotocolmanualprofessionalsDSM-5ICD-11

You might also like